Tony Wadsworth places a metal-plated briefcase on his lap, unclips the lid and pulls out a record. It’s a recent addition to his vinyl collection, one he calls a “unicorn” – an album he’s never owned, one that’s incredibly rare. It’s Fall in a Hole, a legendary Flying Nun live recording of The Fall’s 1982 New Zealand tour. The Guardian reports it’s a “mythical” album: permissions were muddled, front man Mark E Smith was mad, sales were recalled and it nearly ended Flying Nun just as it started. Wadsworth got it from a guy selling all his records and paid about $350 for it. According to the collecting site Discogs a copy in mint condition could be worth more than $600.
Wadsworth isn’t keeping that record. Like every album in his collection, it won’t stay with him for long. He’s a vinyl reseller, and his personal rule is that every album he gets he on-sells, hopefully for a small profit. He’s already listed Fall in a Hole for a very reasonable $425. Yet there’s no denying he’s a collector. He has more than 3000 records and is constantly on the hunt for more, scouring TradeMe listings and Facebook Marketplace looking for rarities and bargains. He’s sharp, often the first to reach out to someone who is letting their collection go. Recently, I met a man in a Henderson carpark doing just that. Wadsworth had beaten me to it. “Some guy called Tony was just here,” the seller told me. “He bought about $500 worth of stuff.” The good ones were all gone.
He’s the antithesis of vinyl collectors who can never get enough and always want more, like this guy. Wadsworth says it’s the only way he can do this job. He calls himself an ambulance service for old records. “This is triage. I’m the nurse. I give them some TLC and send them on their way,” he says. Every find is put through the same process. “I listen to it, I clean it and I grade it so I can get an idea of what it’s worth. Then, fingers crossed, I sell it.” He lists his records through TradeMe and his Facebook page as The Vinyl Vault. (His $1 Monday listings are his most popular nights.) He sells about 100 records a week and says that’s enough to pay his bills. “It’s not making me rich but I’m happy hanging out drinking coffee and playing records,” he says.
Wadsworth has been doing this since 2019. Back then, his time running the Time Saver Traffic radio reports was well over and he was operating a cat hotel in Tauranga with his wife and their children. That’s when he decided it was time to live out his high school dream and work in a record store. Wadsworth scored a part-time job but found having a boss frustrating. “I found a bundle of records in Wellington. I kept saying, ‘Buy the records, buy the records, buy the records’. And he kept saying, ‘No money, no money, no money.’” So Wadsworth thought, “Fuck it, I’ll buy them myself.” A few days later, he was driving back from Upper Hutt with several crates of classic rock records loaded in the boot of his car. They cost him $2500 and they’re long gone.
He’s been selling records like this ever since. After a separation, Wadsworth returned to Auckland a year ago. All the records are in the country’s biggest city, he says, and since Covid the second-hand market is booming. That’s because everyone who spent up large on their record collections during lockdowns are offloading them. “They’re back living their regular lives now and they don’t have time to spare, so now they’re selling their vinyl,” he says. It is, he admits, a far cry from his high school years when record stores were “literally putting vinyl records through shredders because they had so little street value that they just threw them away and put CDs up on shelves”. Wadsworth’s stats prove his appeal: he has nearly 16,000 feedback notes on TradeMe.
I met Wadsworth after buying several of his records, which always seem to be priced cheaply and in great condition. Standing outside his inner-city apartment he told me about his rules, that he refused to keep any of the records that found their way to him. Fascinated, we went for coffee, and he told me he once tried curating a bespoke collection, but it didn’t take. “I very rapidly ended up with a whole bunch of records on a shelf that was actually stock that pays for my rent and pays for my food,” he says. Listening to each record once is enough. “Once I’ve listened to it that one time, when am I going to listen to it again?” Wadsworth says. On a recent Sunday morning, he sent me an image of Silverchair’s Frogstomp on his stereo. “It’s a palate cleanser after Lorde and Kacey Musgraves,” he wrote. “Sepultura next.”
Towards the end of our chat, Wadsworth opened his briefcase and pulled out another record. This, he said, is the only record he would never part with. It came from a 2019 indie-rock cruise between Barcelona and Italy and featured Mogwai, Teenage Fanclub and Belle and Sebastian. Yo La Tengo were also on that cruise, and Wadsworth told me he ran to his room to find his vinyl copy of their soundtrack to the 2009 film Adventureland and asked them to sign it, which they did. Despite their scrawls, he doesn’t think it’s worth much. He’s never had it valued. (On Discogs, the median price is $43.) “I’ve never even played it,” Wadsworth told me as he held it up proudly. In that moment, he sounded just like a collector.
Browse The Vinyl Vault’s listings on TradeMe.

If you love this newsletter and would like to support it, become a contributor! Paying subscribers receive extra newsletters, bonus content and access to the full back catalogue. Plus, you’d be the best person ever, obviously. It’s thanks to everyone who does this that I can send posts like this out for free. Have a great Monday and we’ll talk again soon…

Bonus beat.






